Empezar de nuevo

Guía de Votantes

Magisterial District Judge 05-02-04

Magisterial district judges (MDJs) do not have to be lawyers but are required to pass a qualifying exam. Handle civil cases up to $12,000; responsible whether serious criminal cases go the Court of Common Pleas; handle preliminary arraignments and hearings; minor criminal offenses, traffic citations and non-traffic ordinance violations. Responsible for setting and accepting bail, except in murder or voluntary manslaughter cases.Term of office: 6 yearsSalary: 93,338

Haga clic sobre la foto del candidato para aprender más. Para comparar dos candidatos, haga clic en el botón "compare". Para empezar de nuevo, haga clic sobre la foto de otro candidato.

  • Candidate picture

    Matthew V. Rudzki

  • Candidate picture

    Dave Turner

  • Candidate picture

    Jennifer Evashavik

Información Biográfica

The Criminal Justice Task Force (11/16) recommended that Magistrates use the Allegheny County Risk Assessment tool for pretrial release determinations when setting bail. Are you familiar with this tool? Would you use it to determine the need for bail and the value of bail required?

How will you handle the imbalance of power you will commonly see in your court between vulnerable populations, who can not afford an attorney and will represent themselves the majority of the time, and opposing parties that tend to be more powerful, as the Police, or have the resources to hire an attorney, as a landlord against a tenant.

Last Name Rudzki
First Name Matthew
Middle Name V.
Facebook @mattformagistrate
twitter @matt4magistrate
District MDJ 05-2-04; Aspinwall, Blawnox, Fox Chapel, Indiana, O'Hara, and Sharpsburg
Education Fox Chapel Area School School (2004); Washington & Jefferson College, B.A. History & German (2008); Duquesne University School of Law, J.D. (2013)
Qualifications for office Aspinwall-based, general practice attorney since 2013 with experience handling matters before magistrate courts, Courts of Common Pleas, and administrative bodies. Presently the Mayor of Sharpsburg and former Councilor. Teaching fellowship 2008-2009.
Yes. While the risk assessment tool can serve a purpose in creating consistency in the bail process, the metrics upon which the tool was developed is based upon a flawed criminal justice system that has had and continues to have a disproportionate impact on those with lower incomes and people of color. Accordingly, in addition to the risk assessment tool, magistrates must also perform an inquiry and consider an individual's ability to pay and what would be a reasonable bail amount given the circumstances and charges, while bearing in mind the purpose of bail is to guarantee an individual's appearance unless they present such a threat that no condition can guarantee public safety.
The imbalance of power in our courts stems from systemic inequities within our justice system. I have completed an implicit bias continuing legal education course and would encourage my staff to also take the same course in order to be cognizant of the imbalance. When conducting criminal or landlord-tenant matters and approached by an unrepresented party, I would advise criminal defendants of their right to legal counsel, or in the case of tenants, the availability of pro-bono legal services, and direct them to resources such as the public defender's office, Neighborhood Legal Services, or the Bar Association. If necessary and in order to ensure parties are properly represented, I would grant continuances to impacted parties.

Last Name Turner
First Name Dave
Campaign Web Site http://www.electdaveturner.com
Facebook https://www.facebook.com/ElectDaveTurner
twitter https://twitter.com/ElectDaveTurner
District Magisterial District 05-2-04 (Aspinwall, Blawnox, Fox Chapel, Indiana Township, O’Hara Township, and Sharpsburg)
Education High School - Shady Side Academy; College – University of Pittsburgh (B.A. English); Law School – University of Pittsburgh (J.D.); Graduate School – Slippery Rock University (M. Ed.)
Qualifications for office Attorney with 15 years of litigation experience. Teacher: formerly at Fox Chapel Area High School, currently with Pittsburgh Public Schools. Volunteer legal experience representing abuse victims and disadvantaged divorcing parents. Former firefighter with the Fox Chapel Volunteer Fire Department.
I will regularly consider the pretrial risk assessment algorithm when setting bail. That stated, I will follow the comment to Pennsylvania Rule of Criminal Procedure 523, which states: “A risk assessment tool must not be the only means of reaching the bail determination.” Rule 523 requires a magisterial judge to consider a number of factors to come to a decision about bail. I will follow this Rule, using the risk assessment tool as one of many considerations in determining the need for and value of bail.
In every case, I will always work to reach a fair result according to the law. This will sometimes require additional effort on my part when individuals represent themselves. First, I will attempt to refer people without lawyers to services that provide free legal representation. If that is not available, I will personally question the unrepresented party and witnesses to do my best to understand the relevant facts and arguments. While this may take additional time, it is the best way I know to fairly address the challenges of reaching fair and legally appropriate results when parties are unable to afford legal representation.
Last Name Evashavik
First Name Jennifer
Campaign Web Site http://jenforjudge05204.com
Facebook @jenforjudge05204
District District Court 05-2-04: Aspinwall, Blawnox, Fox Chapel, Indiana, O'Hara and Sharpsburg
Education Westmont Hilltop HS; Wittenberg University, B.A. Political Science; University of Pittsburgh School of Law, J.D.
Qualifications for office Attorney with 20+ years experience in magistrate courts in Allegheny County. Asst. District Attorney for 13 yrs: 6 yrs in District Court 05-2-04. Private practice 7+ yrs. Educator on safety during encounters for first responders, parents and individuals with autism. Former Aspinwall Councilwoman
Yes. I have participated in thousands of bail hearings. Judges must make an independent evaluation of each person’s circumstances when determining bail. Pretrial Services completes the assessment and sends it to the magistrate to review. The assessment is only a recommendation. I would use it as one part of my analysis in setting bail. The purposes of bail are to guarantee a person appears for court and ensure the safety of our community. Other factors to consider include the type of charges, a person’s ability to pay and if a substance abuse or mental illness issue exists. Bail must never be used to punish and no one should be in jail solely because they cannot afford their bail. Alternatives to monetary bail will be used when appropriate.
Working as a prosecutor and a defense attorney, I've seen firsthand the imbalance of power when a party is unrepresented. My experience has prepared me to work effectively with unrepresented individuals. I will adopt best practices learned by spending 20 years in magistrate courts. I will advise unrepresented parties of their right to an attorney and give information on engaging a free attorney through Neighborhood Legal Services or the Public Defender’s office. I will postpone a case when an attorney is requested. If a party self-represents, I will carefully explain and clarify issues during hearings. I will be patient and ensure all parties understand the hearing and decisions made. All parties should leave knowing they had a fair hearing